Critique of the Vessel: An Unjust “Interactive Artwork”

The Vessel, located in Hudson Yards, New York is considered one of the most “instagrammable” works of architecture. The 150 ft work of architecture, which resembles more of a structure, was designed by Thomas Heatherwick. It was inspired by Indian stepwells. So far, the Vessel faces calls for closure after numerous people have tragically committed suicide by falling from the structure. A series of measures have been taken to prevent suicides from occurring again, however it is still known as a controversial work of architecture. Currently, it remains temporarily closed.

The honeycomb, also known as a shawarma like structure, has been denoted as a “stairwell to nowhere” by the New York Times. It was funded by Hudson Yards developer Related Companies with its final cost being estimated at $200 million. What disturbs me the most about the construction of the Hudson Yards Vessel was that it was partially bankrolled by an investor visa program called EB-5, which was meant to assist poverty-stricken areas. Urban poverty was supposed to be alleviated but the Vessel stole wealth from those that need it most. It could have gone to support public housing or community facilities.

It seems that this so called “interactive artwork”, as it referred to on the Vessel website, is merely luxury for show, as a photogenic work to attract tourists. It’s sole purpose is to offer “remarkable views of the city, river, and beyond”. On the website, they also refer to the Vessel as a “soaring new landmark”. Notably, the Indian stepwells, which served as an inspiration for the structure, ensures the availability of water during droughts. It had cultural, religious, and social importance for monsoon dependent India. The stepwells are known as an extravagant piece for public theatre, where collecting water or bathing for religious purposes was visible to all participants and witnesses. The Vessel’s success depends on its façade and sculptural quality, which is a seemingly complex yet unsuccessful geometry. Additionally, the stairwells which consist of 2,400 steps, are only meaningful for exercise. The only plus is that it has many rest stops so you can see the view of the city from the series of balconies.